Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
NEIGHBOURHOOD LEGAL SERVICES
  • Home
  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • Online Intake
  • Tenants Rights Resources
  • Blog
  • careers
  • Make a Donation
  • Contact Us

Landmark 'Right to Housing' Case dismissed by Superior Court

9/11/2013

 
In a lengthy 52 page decision released on Friday, September 6, Mr. Justice Thomas Lederer of the Superior Court of Ontario dismissed the landmark ‘Right to Housing’ case that had been brought by the Advocacy Centre for Tenants Ontario (ACTO) and other housing and homelessness advocates.
ACTO had filed an application in the Superior Court in 2010 on behalf of 4 precariously housed and homeless individuals, and on behalf of the Centre for Equality Rights in Accomodation (CERA). The application alleged that the Governments of Canada and Ontario were in breach of their legal obligations under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms and under international law by failing to put in place a comprehensive strategy to address the affordable housing and homelessness crisis in the country. Specifically, the application alleged that the harm caused by this failure breaches the rights of the applicants under s. 7 (the right to life, liberty and security) and s. 15 (equality rights) of the Charter.

In May, 2012, the Attorney Generals of Canada and Ontario brought a motion to dismiss ACTO’s application without a full hearing, arguing that the application had “no reasonable prospect of success” and therefore, did not meet the legal test for proceeding to a full hearing. A lengthy hearing was held over 3 consecutive days in May, 2013. Justice Lederer’s decision granted the Attorney Generals’ motion and dismissed the application.

Though Justice Lederer stated that he was sympathetic to the issue of inadequate housing, he did not believe that the allegations made in the application raised any breach of the Charter. He also stated that the application was “misconceived” because it was asking the courts to enter into the arena of policy making, and emphasized that the Charter does not guarantee a minimum standard of living. He remained unconvinced by ACTO’s arguments that the application raises important legal and constitutional issues that can only be decided on the basis of a full hearing on the evidence.

Housing and anti-poverty advocates have been disappointed with the decision to not grant a full hearing. Leilani Farha of CERA has questioned the court’s decision to judge the application as being “misconceived” without even listening to the evidence. Lawyers for the applicants plan to appeal the decision to the Ontario Court of Appeal. Such an appeal must be brought within 30 days.

You can read a full text of the decision here.
Sam
9/19/2013 09:22:32 am

This is a very important case for all Canadians. Thank you for the update and for providing the full text of the decision - I haven't been able to find it anywhere else! Goodluck to the plaintiffs on the appeal!


Comments are closed.

    The NLS Blog

    Our blog shares information with our community on legal developments and other important issues. As such we hope you'll find this blog informative - and maybe even fun. 
    Feel free to comment on anything you read here, or to share other interesting news with us. Comments may be moderated to screen for offensive or inappropriate content.


    DISCLAIMER
    This Blog provides general information only and does not provide any legal advice. By viewing this blog, you acknowledge that you have read and understood our full DISCLAIMER. 


    Categories

    All
    Access To Justice
    Charter Of Rights And Freedoms
    Clinic Law
    Family Reunification
    GTA Clinics Transformation Project
    Health Care
    Hoarding
    Homelessness
    Housing
    Human Rights
    Immigration
    Legal Aid
    Legal Clinics
    Mental Health
    Refugee
    Social Assistance & Income Security
    Social Determinants Of Health

Powered by
  • Home
  • About Us
  • What We Do
  • Online Intake
  • Tenants Rights Resources
  • Blog
  • careers
  • Make a Donation
  • Contact Us
"Overcoming poverty is not a gesture of charity. It is an act of justice"
- Nelson Mandela (1918-2013)
About Us

Services

Resources
​
Contact Us

​Blog

News

Careers
The use of this website and any communication with us is subject to
our
Disclaimer and Privacy Policy
​

Neighbourhood Legal Services, 101 - 163 Queen Street East, Toronto, ON M5A 1S1 
Tel: 416.861.0677 | Fax: 416.861.1777
Funded by Legal Aid Ontario
​

Copyright © 2019 NLS.
Some rights reserved
under an Attribution-Non-Commercial Creative Commons License. Click here to view License Deed
Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.